Whereas WeWork’s catastrophic fall from grace might have poor enterprise administration written throughout it, the most recent chapter submitting represents an indictment of the coworking enterprise mannequin as a complete.
The concept of co-working is extra related as we speak than ever earlier than as versatile work has cemented its place globally. The way forward for five-days-a-week, in-person work stays debatable–and corporations throughout the nation have maintained hybrid work choices post-pandemic. This 12 months, 73% of American employees reported working in-office for 3 or extra days per week, with a median of three to 4 days in-person, based on a McKinsey study. Totally distant staff now solely characterize 15% of the workforce, a robust indication that hybrid work, whereas beforehand dubbed the “new normal,” is right here to remain.
WeWork’s lack of ability to make the most of the paradigm shift in industrial actual property is because of the truth that WeWork’s modern model was constructed on the identical conventional phrases that industrial actual property has used for hundreds of years. The co-working enterprise mannequin takes on long-term leases at a locked-in price, inserting an enormous wager on occupancy charges and rents staying excessive. This leaves an enormous danger imbalance within the dedicated time period lengths between landlords and occupants. As disclosed in WeWork’s notorious S-1 filing in 2019, its common lease time period is roughly 15 years. This leaves the corporate providing purchasers versatile lease phrases, whereas they continue to be dedicated throughout rate of interest cycles and market downturns.
When charges are low, and corporations aren’t rigorous about burn, coworking has product-market match. When charges are excessive and wallets are tight, the outcomes might be catastrophic, as evidenced by WeWork’s newest chapter–and that’s whatever the demand for versatile working environments.
As quickly as workplace areas aren’t crammed, it’s the coworking platforms that lose cash, not the landlords. As of Q3 2023, over 20% of American industrial actual property house remained empty, based on JLL. This has created an existential disaster for companies like WeWork, who’re struggling to grapple with an outdated mannequin that has supplied a helpful product for shoppers, however has failed in altering the established order with landlords.
It’s time that we embrace the truth that coworking, whereas billed as an ingenious means to insert vitality and collaboration into the office, is constructed on the inspiration of the identical age-old mannequin that it claims to rework.
Coworkers crave constructing tradition and feeling a way of belonging to their firm, which requires privateness as an alternative of a shared ground with outdoors distractions. Existing research has proved that over 52% of staff want non-public places of work over open ground plans, which is a foundational side of the coworking mannequin. These staff search in-person work to really feel related to their firm’s mission and tradition, to not be part of WeWork’s tradition.
In as we speak’s versatile workplace surroundings, staff are inspired to reap the advantages of the workspace by having the ability to work together intently with their counterparts. If these interactions have gotten much less significant by taking part in coworking, then the mannequin’s key worth proposition is at greatest, failing to deal with the wants of a considerable phase of its buyer base.
In some ways, WeWork’s collapse is simply the tip of the iceberg for a mannequin that did not dwell as much as its expectations. Whereas the office query is clearly a subject that can proceed to be iterated on within the coming years, it’s time that we settle for that co-working isn’t the reply.
Christelle Rohaut is the co-founder and CEO of Codi.
Extra must-read commentary printed by Fortune:
- Financial pessimists’ wager on a 2023 recession failed. Why are they doubling down in 2024?
- COVID-19 v. Flu: A ‘much more serious threat,’ new research into long-term dangers concludes
- Entry to fashionable stoves may very well be a game-changer for Africa’s financial improvement–and assist lower the equal of the carbon dioxide emitted by the world’s planes and ships
- The U.S.-led digital commerce world order is under attack–by the U.S.
The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary items are solely the views of their authors and don’t essentially mirror the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.
